A large segment of the
American Hispanic
community has
historically shared
conservative Republican
values, even though
today many of them vote
Democrat. In fact, a
close look at US history
demonstrates that
Hispanics have
traditionally been
closer to conservative
Republican values than
to those of the Democrat
Party.
The GOP needs to
establish a clear
agenda to reach and
mobilize these
millions of American
Hispanics who are
not getting the
conservative
Republican message.
Their presence in
the party and their
vote is critical and
it is still today a
swing vote up for
grabs. Democrats
should not assume
that American
Hispanics are part
of their base. But
Republicans should
understand the need
to act quickly.
History, the
Press and the
American Hispanics
In the beginning of
this 21st Century,
"American" is what
defines us as a
nation. However, in
order to better
understand the
historical facts
about American
Hispanics, it is
helpful to consider
that states such as
California, Arizona,
New Mexico, Texas,
Louisiana or
Florida, among
others, were home to
Hispanic peoples
even before the
United States gained
independence from
England. These and
other
Spanish-speaking
territories were
originally part of
Spain, and later
Mexico. Many cities
in the United States
were founded in the
16th and 17th
centuries: St.
Augustine, Santa Fe,
Pensacola,
Albuquerque, and
others.
Understanding that
in some parts of the
United States the
Hispanic cultural
roots are older than
the Anglo-Saxon
roots is key to
contextualizing the
reasons why many
generations of
American Hispanics
have largely
maintained their
cultural traditions
and the Spanish
language.
American Hispanics
looked favorably
towards the ideals
of the Republican
Party at the time it
was founded in the
middle of the 19th
Century. The Spanish
settlers who lived
in what back then
was called "Alta
California" resisted
being governed by a
Mexican government
that had won
independence from
Spain in 1810. The
Mexican army
suppressed them and
those men and women
called "Californios"
welcomed "Yankee
Gringos" as
liberators who freed
them from the
Mexican yoke. Like
other American
Hispanics living on
the north of the
Mexican border in
1848, these "Californios"
were among the first
Americans to face
the realities of
being of Hispanic
origin in a
predominantly
Anglo-American
world.
After the 1848
Treaty of Guadalupe
Hidalgo, there were
over 130
Spanish-language or
bilingual newspapers
published in the
United States during
the second half of
the 19th century.
Many of these
bilingual newspapers
printed laws and
public notices
bilingually or in
Spanish. They
embraced the ideas
of freedom, moral
and material
progress implemented
in the United
States. Most of
these newspapers in
the Spanish language
supported the
magnanimous ideals
of the U.S.
Declaration of
Independence and
those of equality,
democracy and civil
liberties espoused
in the U.S.
Constitution. Out of
a section in the
"Los Angeles Star" (LA´s
first bilingual
newspaper since
1851) evolved "El
Clamor Público" (The
Public Outcry) in
1855, edited by
Francisco P. Ramírez.
As an American
Hispanic, Ramírez
tried to take the
best from both
worlds, finding his
own democratic
thinking was best
reflected in the
Republican Party
ideals of the day.
In the 1850s there
were numerous
articles in Spanish
in "El Clamor
Público"
articulating the
views of most of
these "Californios".
As a representative
newspaper in Spanish
of its times, we
find praises to the
U.S. Constitution ("Alabanza
de la Constitución
Americana"), to
George Washington
and to American
history. It did not
stand apart from the
debates over slavery
that increasingly
gripped politics in
the United States.
In fact, its
hostility to slavery
propelled many
American Hispanics
into the Republican
Party when it
emerged in the 1850s
with a platform of
opposition to the
spread of human
bondage to the West.
We also find opinion
editorials that
openly supported and
even asked for the
American Hispanic
vote for the
Republican Party and
for the candidacy of
John C. Fremont, the
GOP´s first ever
candidate for
president in 1856.
They openly
confronted and even
disqualified
Democrat
presidential
candidates such as
James Buchanan, Jr.
In a region
controlled by
southern Democrats,
who brought the
prevailing racial
attitudes of the
cotton-producing
region with them
when they migrated
to California,
newspapers such as
"El Clamor Público"
defended the
principles and ideas
of the Republicans.
By 1859 this
newspaper advised
its readers about
the need to learn
English, to
understand that
American Hispanics
were under the
American flag and
about the importance
to become
Americanized all
over, in language,
in manners, in
customs and in
habits. In the 1859
election, the same
newspaper publicized
Republican
candidates such as
Leland Stanford for
governor. Ramírez
himself ran for the
assembly on the
Republican ticket.
Other American
Hispanic leaders
such as Abel
Stearns, Manuel
Raquena, and José
Fuentes actively
supported the
Republican Party and
Abraham Lincoln's
war effort. They
organized rallies
and urged their
fellow compatriots
to vote Republican
policies as a duty
to which they owed
to themselves.
The Spanish-American
war in 1898 created
some turmoil between
Spain, the Hispanic
world and the United
States. Throughout
the 20th Century,
the Democrats were
able to shape the
image of the GOP as
the party of the
anti-immigrant,
anti-Hispanic, the
"Know Nothings"...
when, in fact, that
was not the case. In
1972, for example,
Richard Nixon began
the
"Spanish-Speaking
Committee," greatly
expanded by other
Republican
presidents. In 1979,
President Ronald
Reagan stated the
idea that American
Hispanics are
Republicans.
Presidents such as
George W. Bush
recognized the
importance of
offering American
Hispanics a voice in
his administration
and opened the doors
wide and welcomed
them to
unprecedented levels
of political access
and participation in
government.
The GOP and
the American
Hispanics
Despite the
continuous attempts
to present the
Republican Party and
the conservatives as
anti-immigrant and
anti-Hispanic, the
facts point to the
reality that the
percentage of
American Hispanics
who call themselves
Democrats has
declined in the last
decade, even as the
overall number of
Hispanic voters has
climbed. In
California, for
instance, home to
the nation's largest
American Hispanic
population and an
important center of
55 electoral votes
for the next 2008
presidential
election, nearly two
of three American
Hispanic voters were
registered Democrats
in the mid-1990s.
According to polling
and registration
data, that figure
dropped as low as 56
percent by 2006.
Recent research by
the Public Policy
Institute of
California found
that American
Hispanics in
California are about
equally divided
among those who
describe themselves
as conservative,
liberal and
moderate. Immigrants
of Hispanic origin
who become citizens
and register to vote
become Democrats in
nearly 70 percent of
the cases, with
Republican
registration at 18
percent. It is easy
to see Democrat
activists outside
the judicial courts
waiting to register
the newly pledged
citizens with the
Democrat Party. And
yet, in the second
generation, Democrat
registration drops
to 56 percent and
GOP registration
increases to 25
percent. By the
third U.S.-born
generation, Democrat
and Republican
registration among
Hispanics is nearly
equal.
According to a 2005
report by the Pew
Hispanic Center, 77%
of American
Hispanics oppose
abortion. Thus, the
Democrat Party is
anathema to the
values of the
American Hispanic
community in terms
of life issues.
According to the
2005 National Latino
Survey, 62% of
American Hispanics
oppose gay marriage
and 48% of
registered voters in
that same community
agree that lowering
taxes is the best
strategy for
encouraging economic
growth, as compared
to 12% who thought
raising taxes is the
best strategy. It is
true that American
Hispanic voters are
not firmly attached
to either party, and
they have voted in
sizable numbers for
GOP candidates who
appeal on values
that American
Hispanics share.
Unfortunately, and
with the exception
of the Reagan years
and the Bush 2004
re-election
campaign, the GOP
has not yet figured
out how to attract
American Hispanic
voters...not by
abandoning core
beliefs or by
pandering to
non-conservative
Republican issues,
but playing to their
strengths.
Yet, it is important
not to let the
mainstream media
convince us that
Republicans have
abandoned the
Hispanic vote.
Democrats and others
have long been
dismissing the
Republican Party's
progress with
Hispanic voters.
Largely because of
Ronald Reagan, the
GOP has become a
viable contender
within the
community. As we
have seen over the
last several
elections, that
relationship has
grown stronger.
While the Democrats
look at the American
Hispanics as
victims-just as they
do with American
Africans-the
Republicans look at
the American
Hispanic community
as people who have
contributed to the
cultural fiber of
the United States in
many ways. As the
largest minority
group in the nation,
many of them have
followed the
American Dream, an
ideal that the
Republican Party
highly believes in
and endorses.
Republicans need to
hammer the idea that
they are the party
who really want to
bring our country
forward, providing
opportunity for all
who are willing to
achieve this dream.
The most
controversial issue
deals with
undocumented /
illegal immigration.
The GOP must propose
real solutions to
this particular
issue and should
fight against anyone
who brands the
Republican Party as
"anti-immigrant"
because it
understands that
strengthening our
immigration system
requires upholding
the rule of law.
It is also time to
break with the idea
that Democrats are
more sensitive to
Hispanic needs than
Republicans. Polls
show that American
Hispanic voters will
support any
preconditions to
legal immigration,
including forcing
undocumented
immigrants to return
to their native
countries for a
time, so long as a
possible path to
migrate under the
right legal venues
is created. It needs
to be said that
registered American
Hispanic voters
often take
conservative
positions on
immigration issues.
In 2004, 47 percent
supported
Proposition 200,
which required proof
of citizenship for
government benefits.
In 2006, 48 percent
voted to make
English the official
language.
Education is one of
the top issues of
concern for American
Hispanics. The
progressive liberal
recipes provided by
Democrats on this
area have been
failing for decades.
The Republican Party
should promote
school choice among
Hispanic families
and voters. Surveys
show that nearly
two-thirds of
Hispanics support
school choice.
Religion is another
area to attract
Hispanics to the
Republican side.
Christian values,
particularly
Catholic ones, are
central to the lives
of most American
Hispanics whose
approach to religion
is based on true
conservative
principles. The
recent visit of Pope
Benedict XVI clearly
showed how American
Hispanics are moved
by core values such
as their opposition
to abortion.
Republicans can
obtain substantial
electoral gains by
taking these issues
as a direct and
honest message to
American Hispanic
voters. They should
speak clearly about
their opponents'
opposition to the
conservative values
shared by American
Hispanic households.
For that purpose, it
is imperative for
the GOP to create a
real American
Hispanic outreach.
Republican leaders
need to go into
heavily Democrat
voting districts and
send these messages
to the American
Hispanic families
and communities.
Communication is a
key area and this is
why creating
conservative opinion
in the Spanish
language is
important,
especially for the
first generation of
American Hispanics.
In 2004, supporters
of President Bush
sponsored thousands
of Spanish-language
advertisements in
swing states,
focusing on such
issues as
traditional
marriage, tax breaks
for families and
small businesses,
school choice and
faith-based social
initiatives. In the
states with targeted
advertising, the
share of American
Hispanics voting
Republican
substantially
increased.
Although Hispanic
Republicans have won
significant offices
in some states,
there are still few
American Hispanic
Republicans holding
offices across the
United States,
particularly in the
Southwest region.
They seem to be at a
loss when it comes
to win contested
primaries against
Democrat opponents
who have a
domesticated
Hispanic lobby and
who have actually
done little or
nothing to improve
the lives of
American Hispanics.
The GOP should work
aggressively to
recruit Hispanic
candidates who share
conservative
Republican values
and to reach out to
American Hispanic
voters on issues of
mutual concern.
Failing to do so
will not only
increase the losses
in Congress, but it
will also mean to be
blind to American
history and to the
conservative mind of
American Hispanics.